Choose the seam
Identify the interface or workflow boundary that will change. Use supported transaction examples and a versioned baseline to make the current behavior reviewable.
A seam might be an API, an asynchronous handoff or a business workflow boundary. Document who calls it, what state it changes and which outcomes callers rely on. Include exceptions, ordering and partial completion; a replacement that matches only the happy path may alter the business meaning of the service.
- Name consumers and downstream services.
- Record the interface versions in scope.
- Define the business outcomes that must remain unchanged.
Build comparable alternatives
Keep workload and input conditions stable while changing the proposed service behavior or dependency.
Change one declared aspect at a time when practical. If the candidate also changes demand, data distribution or the failure model, record those differences explicitly. Otherwise an apparent improvement may come from an easier workload rather than a better service design.
Paired paths under the same declared workload
Hold input cases, demand and relevant data assumptions stable.
- Pin baseline and candidate models.
- Include expected failures and partial completion.
- Document unsupported vendor and protocol paths.
Prepare the release decision
Compare business invariants and client outcomes, then decide which evidence must be reproduced in the intended deployment.
Explain each material difference as preserved behavior, an intended change, a regression or an unresolved discrepancy. The evidence should help reviewers decide what needs further testing on the actual target platform. Simulation acceptance is a rehearsal milestone, not authorization for production cutover.
Can an authored replacement preserve a legacy booking handoff?
Feed the same synthetic bookings and exception cases into current and candidate paths. Compare identifiers, final booking states, repeated requests and partial completion.
A matching happy path is insufficient if a duplicate request changes the booking twice. Record the difference and the native integration tests required to resolve it.
- Retain regression evidence and exceptions.
- Identify rollback and recovery assumptions.
- Separate model acceptance from production cutover approval.
Make compatibility observable
Define compatibility in terms of the outcomes consumers depend on. Response structure is only one part of the contract; timing assumptions, state transitions, identity, retries and exception semantics may also matter.
Use independent assertions at the chosen service boundary. Where vendor behavior or a protocol path is unsupported, state the gap and design a separate integration test rather than treating a generic model as native-system evidence.
Classify differences before deciding
| Difference | Interpretation | Review action |
|---|---|---|
| Same business result | Behavior is preserved for the declared cases. | Check excluded paths and deployment assumptions. |
| Intended contract change | Consumers must understand the new behavior. | Version and test the changed contract explicitly. |
| Unexpected state or duplicate effect | The replacement may break compatibility. | Investigate and retain the regression evidence. |
- Map consumer expectations and side effects.
- Retain interface and model versions.
- Test intended differences explicitly.
Rehearse failure and rollback assumptions
A migration can fail between a request and its downstream effect. Include partial completion, delayed responses and recovery sequencing in the authored scenario. Identify which state belongs to each side of the boundary.
Rollback is not simply switching an endpoint if the candidate has changed data or emitted effects. Document what can be reversed, what requires reconciliation and what must be handled through a separate recovery procedure in the target environment.
Keep the evidence and its conditions together. A later success does not erase an earlier failure or broaden the original scope.
- Record state ownership before and after the change.
- Include unknown outcomes and repeated requests.
- Keep restoration and reconciliation evidence with the release review.
Prepare a bounded modernization review
Choose the smallest service boundary that can support a useful decision. Review the paired results with both the consuming team and the owner of the proposed replacement.
The review package should explain preserved behavior, intentional differences, failures and unsupported paths. Agree the customer integration and operational tests needed before moving from a modeled rehearsal to a deployment decision.
Review preparation
0 / 6 prepared- Pin baseline and candidate artifacts.
- Name the unresolved compatibility gaps.
- Keep cutover authorization as a separate gate.